Fourth Review – Molinari

Taco Bell VS. Taco ‘bout Sushi:

Taco Bell, a somewhat well known and arguably acclaimed chain of restaurants, is likely the biggest competition an up and coming Taco Sushi/Sushi Taco shop can face. While “Taco ‘bout Sushi” has a clear advantage of offering two delicious types of food in one easy to acquire package, “Taco Bell” has the advantage of being a multi-million chain restaurant with decades of experience and customer loyalty under their belt offering products at a third the of our prices. Needless to say, as the future go to Taco place, Taco Bell is our greatest adversary.

Examining their website is an adventure into bright colors and pictures of food. While one might associate mexican food with more earthy tones and dark greens, Taco bell makes the interesting choice going with a palette of rich purple and dark blacks. This is an odd choice, purple isn’t a color associated with fast food or mexican, nor have the advantage the color red has of stimulating hunger. While not exactly intuitive for a mexican restaurant it would stick out like a sore thumb when compared to the humble “Taco ‘bout Sushi” website. We go with a more traditional color scheme, featuring shades of brown and off whites, combining taco shell orange with salmon-ish pink. It’s not over stimulating and while has a more varied palette feels more welcoming. Taco Bell’s purple feels empowered, bold,  and loud. This feels extreme for a mexican restaurant, or in our case, the humble sushi taco. Perhaps the in-your-face feeling is appealing to some, but doesn’t feel suited for the style of restaurant.

Taco Bell made an interesting decision when building the layout of the site. While many similar websites, including “Taco ‘bout Sushi”, choose to place a navigation bar at the top of the page, roughly eye level for any visitors, Taco Bell instead places their navigation bar on the left hand side. This features a few options, including Food, an online menu/opportunity to order food; Locations, a simple search for taco bells in your area; The Feed, a Taco Bell News page; Live Mas; a page about Taco Bell’s charitable actions; and a “More” tab.  Opening “More” pulls out a tab from the side. The tab includes links to a news page, carreer opportunities, Nutrition facts, an online apparel store, a contact page, and their “About” page for the company. Despite being organized, it’s more cluttered. It feels like there’s always more to see, which while is good incentive for a customer to search the entire site is also nigh overwhelming. The color scheme is fitting for the design, to say the least. There is navigation bar at the top of the screen, but given how small the text is and the options available it’s clear the side bar is the main attraction. It allows a search of the menu, a “log in” option, and an easy search for a restaurant near you. “Taco ‘bout Sushi” is a simpler, humbler layout. A logo in one corner and basic location information in the other, all other aspects of the site can be navigated to via our navigation bar at the top of the page. It’s a constant part of the page, making it easy to get anywhere from anywhere on the site. It’s simple and clean, thoroughly intuitive, and most of all all about putting the customer first.

At first glance navigating the Taco Bell website seems fairly intuitive. Everything is correctly labeled, but the labels aren’t quite obvious, in particular “The Feed” and “Live Mas”. The feed, while revealed to be a pun if explored, could be any number of things for a mexican restaurant. It makes sense, but most hungry customers won’t care enough to check. Live Mas, the latest taco bell slogan, means “live more”. While it’s debatable if you’re truly living without sushi in your tacos, the problem lies more in the use of spanish. Mas, a simple word, still isn’t part of the American vocalbularly. It, like the rest of the website, is more about encouraging further exploration of the site rather than the simple “A to B” route that would best serve the customer. That being said, it at least succeeds at its purpose. The true confusion comes, however, with clicking the “food” tab. It presents large pictures of food, with the interesting design choice of scrolling down unveiling a new layer/section of the menu. It’s a very intriguing “animation”, but seems unnecessarily complicated and serves little more than to throw the visitor off.

On paper Taco Bell’s website clearly trumps the “Taco ‘bout sushi”. It’s bold, makes creative design choices, and has obvious brand recognition on its side. Where our website really shines though is the idea of “deafening silence”. The simplicity of the design and muted colors make it more visually appealing. It’s not overbearing and is a good representation of the product sold. Our site is one that a grandma could  use with confidence. Taco Bell, while the gateway to delicious tacos, over complicates what could be a simple process.

Is Invisible- Site Review

http://isinvisible.com/

“Is Invisible”, surprisingly and unfortunately, is not a website looking to sell invisibility cloaks and comic book X-ray specs, rather recommending a products and gadgets designed to be as minimalist as possible.  The general theme of its wares can be described as “clean efficiency”. It’s worth noting the website doesn’t actively sell goods, rather acting as a hub for minimalist products.

Much like the gadgets and gear the site advertises, the website is all about efficiency. Nothing is flashy. The color scheme of the site itself is monochromatic, existing entirely within the gray-scale. The products themselves are showcased in color, but even then they’re more muted than saturated. It’s about displaying a realistic look at the products, not demanding attention towards any one thing. Further safeguarding the calm design the website doesn’t house video or banner advertisements. No need for Ad-block here.

 

The products are split into two columns, one on either side of the screen. There’s a simple picture of each product, the price, and then the next product. Rinse and repeat. The name of the site sits at the upper left corner of the page and will scroll down with the page. A question mark sits in the lower right. Clicking it pulls up a what is essentially a text box explaining the idea behind the website, as well as naming the two people maintaining the site. Clicking on any of the products opens up another page, to the site that sells the desired product.

 

Being a single page site, the only real navigation is scrolling up or down. This design choice is perfect for the site, again keeping with the minimalistic theme. As a person well versed with the internet, scrolling down was a natural progression to navigate the site. Someone less accustomed may have trouble, as there’s no obvious hint that there’s more below. This could be seen as a flaw, but given the nature of the site it’s perfectly acceptable. Adding even an arrow pointing down, or having the next product picture visible at the bottom of the page, would disrupt the clean looking site.

 

As implied, the website is perfectly designed for its purpose. The benefit of the sites theme matching the theme of the products it advertises is subtle but brilliant. It’s clean, minimalist, but still extremely clear on with how to navigate. It’s incredibly well designed for its purpose. The only thing that doesn’t work is the prices. They certainly aren’t minimalist.

~Jeremy Molinari

First Review

Newegg is an online computer and electronics retailer. The home page opens with marquee showcasing sales and little reminders of why you might need to buy from them. Below it there are daily sales, and below that rave review of the website itself. This is an interesting design choice, as it lets the customer first get drawn in with the products before actively selling itself, i.e. “you need this, and here’s why you should buy from us”. At the top of the page are three drop down menus leading to various parts of the site. The first breaks the items available into categories for easy navigation. The second showcases more deals, and the third is a list of hyperlinks to their various sellers.

The “all products” tab is where I first began looking for a product. As Newegg is a computer-centric website, computing parts is at the top of the list with alternatives listed in descending order of relevance. I went to a tab labeled “electronics”, and a tab opened to the side, further breaking down down the category. I wasn’t going in with any particular plan, so I instead just clicked on the electronics tab to be brought to a page version of the break down tab.

The use of the breakdown tab is a great piece of web design, as it not only offers a quick way to see if a hyperlink will be useful before clicking over, but also serving to de-clutter navigation. It’s a simple, but effective tool to help keep consumers oriented.

 

The electronics page was a blown up version of the tab. With a specific goal in mind navigating would be easy. Just scrolling down the website felt packed, but not necessarily crowded. Almost every inch of screen real estate is used, with just enough buffer room between sections to keep it from being overwhelming.

Clicking on a product generalization, in my case HDMI cables, the following screen is a lot cleaner. It’s less pushing options and more just presenting products. Below each products if the price, and in a neat twist, the shipping as well. If there’s anything that makes this website stand out, it’s just that cool little feature. The design itself is comparable to Amazon, but how cleanly the shipping is presented is a massive, massive thumbs up in my book.

 

I selected my HDMI to HDMI mini cable and added it to my cart. On one side of the page there were suggestions for other, similar products, while on the other a picture of my cable and an option to finish the sale or continue shopping. I chose to continue shopping, which led me back to the page I selected a cable from. That little detail is also noteworthy, as if it just went back to the home screen navigating back could be a pain, but getting back to the home screen from there is a simple click away.

Overall, Newegg is not a particularly spectacular website, with its design being comparable to Amazon or similar retailers, but it has a couple of neat tricks to keep things decluttered and make navigation easy. It’s clear and concise, especially if you’ve grown up using similar websites.

 

 

 

http://www.newegg.com/